|zejd.peqin||-- 11-01-2010 @ 3:15 PM|
Is it a condition to advise before warning?:Shaykh Zaid al Madkhalee
سئل الشيخ العلامة زيد المدخلي
هل يشترط النصيحة قبل التحذير؟
أجاب الشيخ حفظه الله :
التحذير نصيحة ، التحذير من فعل الحرام من فعل البدع على اختلاف أنواعها من المخالفات هو نصيحة للناس فلا فرق بين التحذير من الحرام باختلاف أنواعه وبين النصيحة
Shaykh Zayd Al Madkhali was asked:Is it a condition to advise before warning?
So the Shaykh may Allah preserve him said: Warning is advice, warning from carrying out Haraam and warning from carrying out Bidah (innovations) in all of its forms from all that which apposes (the Sunnah) is advice to the people, so there is no difference between warning from that which is Haraam and its different forms and advice.
Taken from http://www.sahab.net/forums/showthread.php?t=372346
|zejd.peqin||-- 19-11-2010 @ 10:19 AM|
A Reply to the Doubt of Those who Claim it is a Condition to Deliver Advice before Spreading a Refutation
- Imaam Muhaddith Al-Albani
The Imaam, rahimahullaah clarifies this doubt, and explains why the delivering of advice before spreading a refutation cannot be taken as a condition.
From the Manhaj of the Muhaddith, Shaykh, Allamaaı
Muhammad Nasiruddeen al-Albaani
Concerning Boycotting the
People of Bidaı
Abbas Abu Yahya
The Issue of giving Advice before Spreading a Refutation
Shaykh Albaani was asked:
ıWhat branches off from this[previous question: mentioning the good deeds of an individual while refuting him] is the statement of some of the people or more correctly should I say, the condition set by some of the people who say that in the case of refutations itıs necessary before it being printed, that a copy is sent to the one being refuted so that they can look into it. They say that this is from the Manhaj of the Salaf?ı
Shaykh Albaani answers:
ıThis is not a condition, however if itıs easy to do, and it is hoped from this practice to bring that person closer without making the case well-known between the people, then there is no doubt that this matter is good.
As for firstly making it a condition, and then secondly making it a general condition then this is not at all from wisdom in any circumstances.
The people, as you all know, are of different natures, like the natures of gold and silver. So the one whom you know from him that he is with us on the path and methodology and that he would accept the advice, wherein you can at least write to him without making his mistake public as you see it, then this is good.
However, this is not a condition, even if this was a condition itıs not a possible matter, where can you get that personıs address? How can you contact him? Then, will you get a response from him or not? These are matters which are absolutely speculative.. . . . implementing this condition is very difficult, that is why this point is not conditional.ı
[Taken from the cassette entitled: ıal-Muwwazanaat Fee Naqdı Side A from the ıSilsilah al-Huda wa Noorı No.638]