Member
Posts: 141
Joined: Dec 2006
|
As-Salaamu AlaiKum,
I had 2 main questions related to pictures\images that are buging me.
They are both (sort-of) linked. So if some student of knowledge could please answer.
Following on from the fact that images of living beings are forbidden in Islaam, I wanted to ask about some related issues that i have come accross.
 | quote: |
| On some educational material (where the images of living beings is missing), sometimes, body-parts are drawn (like a hand pointing to something or holding a pen, or a headless person performing Salah, etc). |
|
Firstly: A brother mentioned that there is a hadith which states that drawing body-parts of a living being (for example: a hand, or a foot, or an arm), this is similar to drawing the image of the living, and so not allowed (he mentioned [with his mouth] a hadith (i think) in Abu Dawood, but gave no reference; and i dont know if this statement is true and if there is such a hadith).
1) Does anyone know if such a hadith exist? (maybe in a different hadith book).
And 2) is it reliable?
And Secondly: I came accross the following;
| quote: |
"The head is what makes something an image. So if the head is cut off, then there is no (forbidden) image."
Hadeeth Number #3864 of Saheeh al-Jaami as-Sagheer wa Ziyaadatuh' |
|
3) Is this hadith\reference correct?
and 4) does this mean that there is nothing wrong with (for example) an image of a headless person performing salah? (which may depend on how strong\or weak my first point is).
Subhaanaka Allaahumma wa bihamdika, ash-hadu an-laa ilaa'ha illa Anta, Astagh'firuka wa atoobu ilayk
(Glory is to You, O Allah, and All praise is to You. I bear witness that there is none worthy of worship but You (alone). I seek Your forgiveness and r
|
|
msaqib2
20-10-2009 @ 12:57 AM
